I love Philly, and I also kind of love the fact that so many people other people hate it. I can totally understand why other people don't like it here, in a lot of ways, this city doesn't even try. If you are open to liking Philly, there's a lot you have to discover for yourself. It's not a destination city like New York or San Francisco. But I don't want to live in New York or San Francisco, because both of them are too expensive, New York is too overwhelming and San Francisco is too far away. I have been to most of the states in this country, and this is the place where I feel most comfortable. Yes, it's a dirty city with a corrupt government, high crime, and rude people. But it's also a city full of greenspaces and history and some of the most awesome people I have ever met. And I feel like I'm part of a secret club of other people who see Philly in this light.
I never thought I would live in a city other than New York. In fact, when I first moved here, I was full of complaints about how small everything is and how early everything closes. At my first job in Philly, I satrted a lot of sentences with, "Well, in New York. . ." and was greeted with faces that pretty much said, "Bitch, if New York is so great, why don't you go back there?" I figured every young person who lives here would rather be in New York, if it wasn't so expensive. Imagine my surprise when I found that lots of people here actually don't like New York at all. I still think New York's an awesome city, but the longer I stay in Philly, the more I know that New York is not my city. It's really hard to make New York your own city, because so many people want a piece of that city. It's a lot easier to make an imprint here, as Center City Philly is really just a big small town.
Sometimes I feel like the only person in America without a raging hard-on for the West Coast. I definitely appreciate the beauty I have seen out there, but whenever I'm there I feel a certain kind of rootlessness that lets me know it's not my home. People are always shocked to hear that I'm not interested in the West Coast. It seems like when you live in Philly, you're supposed to acknowlege that you want to be somewhere else; you're supposed defer to the "great" cities and yearn for nicer weather or whatever. But guess what, I don't. West Coast, I'm just not that into you.
I know I can't convince most people that Philly is a great place to be, and like my city, I'm not sure I really want to try. Philly turned out to be the perfect fit for me: I love history. I love tiny cobblestone streets and three hundred year old rowhomes and Ben Franklin memorobilia. I also love distinct seasons, especially crunching pretty colored leaves in the fall. I love being home drinking hot chocolate while it snows outside. I love the first days of spring when the city comes alive. I love winter fashion. I love that even though a lot of people think I'm out of my mind, there are others here who understand.
5 Responses to “Philadelphia: A love song”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
September 23rd, 2006 at 2:39 pm
Hi! Recent reader to your blog, and I think this is my first comment here…
Just wanted to say that I love this post. It reminds me so much of my own experiences when I left NYC, assuming that everyone thought it was as wonderful and perfect (in its imperfection) as I did, but whenever I mentioned it (which apparently was a lot), I got those same looks. I spent 6 years in Baltimore and finally learned to stop comparing it to NYC (they are really so incredibly different), but yet it never quite felt like home and I think for that reason, I never got over NYC. I am much more optimistic about Philly, even though I don't know how long I'll be here. But I feel like it already satisfies a lot of what I miss about NYC that Baltimore never could do, while still truly having its own charm. I haven't gotten to do a whole lot of exploring unfortunately (I have this dissertation that just won't die), but I am really looking forward to a time when I can get to know Philly better! I am glad to read that you have come to love it.
September 24th, 2006 at 4:46 pm
Hey, thanks! I don't know when it happened for me, but I definitely stopped missing New York. I think it's because I am so spoiled here — I can walk anywhere I need to go, I can afford to live in a nice neighborhood, I can eat at 95% of the restaurants here in a sweatshirt and jeans, etc. I also appreciate how un-crowded it is here most of the time. I hope you fins stuff to love in Philly, too. (If not, well, New York's only a couple hours away. . .)
:)
September 26th, 2006 at 7:43 am
I'm a born & bred, and love it here. I grew up in the Northeast (which reeked of suburb-wannabe), and love Center City, which most of my family doesn't get.
September 27th, 2006 at 10:44 am
I love Philly down to my toes, but having grown up on the West Coast, I have to admit that it tugs at me a little. Part of that is that my parents and sister are still out in Portland, if they were here, I don't think I'd ever have any desire to move. I love Center City, I love that I know so many people here, I love being able to walk places and I love the history. It really is a wonderful city.
September 27th, 2006 at 12:36 pm
Wow, Marisa, I think you're the only West Coast-er I've ever met who likes Philly. I know a lot has to do with where your base is, which is why even though I can appreciate how pretty things are in other places, I would rather not live anywhere that is far removed from my family. It's weird how Philadelphia sometimes seems to have a city-wide self esteem problem. I think there's so much going on here!